Etiology

Among otherwise healthy adults, high-energy trauma (e.g., motor vehicle accidents), sports injuries, falls, and assaults are the main causative factors.

Risk factors for insufficiency fractures include osteoporosis and other chronic metabolic disease, advanced age, prolonged corticosteroid use, female sex, lower BMI, history of a recent fall, and prior fracture.[20] Risk factors for development of femoral stress fractures include high running mileage, female sex, and female athlete triad (disordered eating, menstrual dysfunction, and decreased bone mineral density).[21][22][23]

Humeral shaft fractures:

  • Commonly result from direct trauma to the humerus and falls onto the outstretched hand.[24][25] Less commonly, extreme muscle contraction, electrocution injury, or seizure may lead to humeral shaft fracture.[26]

Proximal humeral shaft fractures:

  • Typically seen in older people after a fall on the outstretched hand. Direct trauma and seizures may also lead to these fractures.[27]

Humeral stress fractures:

  • Primarily occur as a result of overuse among throwing athletes. Gymnasts, weightlifters, and other athletes who place repetitive high-impact or -torque loads on the humerus have also been known to sustain these injuries.

Radial and ulnar shaft fractures:

  • Radial shaft fractures usually result from a fall onto the outstretched or pronated wrist, or from a direct blow. High-torque forces from twisting injuries can also cause such injuries.

  • Isolated fractures of the mid shaft of the ulna, often called nightstick fractures, usually result from a person trying to ward off a blow from a heavy, blunt object (e.g., a night stick or truncheon). If the ulnar fracture involves the proximal third of the shaft, there may be associated dislocation of the radial head at the elbow (Monteggia fracture/dislocation). Monteggia fractures are usually due to a fall onto the outstretched hand, with the elbow extended and pronated.[28]

  • Concomitant fractures of both the radius and the ulna are usually the result of high-energy trauma from a blow, fall, or motor vehicle accident.

Radial and ulnar stress fractures:

  • Primarily occur among athletes who repetitively load the bones with high forces (e.g., gymnasts).[29][30]

Femoral shaft fractures:

  • Generally caused by high-energy trauma, such as a motor vehicle accident, or fall from a height.

  • Spiral fractures of the femoral shaft may occur as a result of a twisting injury.

  • Comminuted and open fractures may occur from gunshot wounds or other forms of high-energy penetrating trauma.

Femoral stress fractures:

  • Commonly seen in athletes and runners.

Tibial and fibular shaft fractures:

  • Tibial shaft fractures may result from direct trauma (usually causes transverse or comminuted fractures) or indirect twisting forces (usually causes spiral or oblique fractures).[31]

  • High-energy trauma may result in simultaneous fracture of both the tibial and fibular shafts.

  • Isolated fibular fractures are typically caused by a direct blow to the outer aspect of the leg or from an external rotation force at the ankle.

Tibial and fibular stress fractures:

  • Stress fractures are relatively common in impact athletes, such as runners and basketball players, and in military personnel.[32][33]

  • Stress fractures of the fibula are uncommon but typically occur in runners and ballet dancers.

Pathophysiology

In otherwise healthy bone, if resorption exceeds formation, the bone will begin to wear down. There are two varieties of stress fracture: fatigue fractures and insufficiency fractures. Fatigue fractures result from repetitive submaximal stress on previously healthy bone, leading to local accelerated bone remodeling (e.g., in the setting of new or repetitive athletic activity).[1][2]​​​ Insufficiency fractures occur due to normal activity on bones that are deficient in microstructure and/or mineralization (e.g., osteoporosis).[1][34]​ If a fracture develops without significant trauma in an area of diseased bone (i.e., bone which is compromised by tumor or other disease process), this is termed a pathologic fracture.[35][36]

Acute fracture of a long bone causes moderate to severe pain, as well as impairment of function. Many long bone fractures are associated with significant bleeding from the bone itself and from injured soft tissues and nearby vessels. Although this bleeding can be severe and even life-threatening (e.g., when a major vessel is lacerated), the hematoma that forms around the ends of the fracture serves as the start of the fracture healing process. Acute inflammatory mediators and cells head to and proliferate in and about the hematoma. While this may lead to increased local swelling and pain, the inflammatory response is an important part of healing. Data from animal studies suggest that nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) may impair healing of fractures, but in vivo studies involving human subjects have failed to confirm a detrimental effect associated with short-term use of NSAIDs following a fracture.[37][38][39]

The fracture hematoma also serves as a scaffold for subsequent callus formation. Within 8 hours of injury, increased cell division occurs in the periosteum and throughout the injured bone. Over the next few days, this increased cell division becomes more localized to the area of the fracture, and this continues for several weeks. In addition, mesenchymal stem cells are recruited to the fracture site, where they multiply and differentiate into osteogenic cells. This leads to the development of a soft cartilaginous callus between the fracture ends and superficial to the periosteum. This occurs about 7 to 10 days after the injury and starts to stabilize the fracture. Simultaneously, a central, hard callus starts to form subjacent to the periosteum, between the ends of the fracture.

Multiple growth factors allow for the development and ingrowth of new blood vessels to provide an adequate blood source for the ongoing work of healing. Hard cartilaginous callus formation peaks by around day 14 post injury, and this cartilage starts to become replaced by woven bone. This remodeling process starts 3 to 4 weeks post injury, and is implemented by osteoclasts resorbing the hard callus and osteoblasts depositing lamellar bone. Eventually, the external aspect of the callus becomes lamellar bone and the internal aspect is re-formed into a medullary cavity.[40]

Assuming proper stabilization and adequate blood supply, some long bone fractures achieve union within 8 weeks, although others (e.g., certain tibial shaft fractures) may take 4 to 6 months to heal.[41][42][43] Functional recovery of long bone fractures may take months beyond the point at which clinical and radiographic union occur, and the process of remodeling may not be fully complete for years.

Classification

General characterization of long bone fractures

Acute

  • Caused by a sudden overload of forces on healthy bone that exceeds the capacity of the bone to withstand those forces.

Stress

  • Fatigue:[1][2]

    • Gradual overload of force on previously healthy bone that exceeds the bone's ability to repair itself over time, leading to a disruption in bone continuity. For example, in the setting of new or repetitive athletic activity.

  • Insufficiency:[1]

    • Force load on bone is normal but fracture occurs in bone that has abnormally low density due to a nonmalignant process, such as osteoporosis.

Pathologic

  • Fracture that occurs in an area of diseased bone (e.g., where the bone has been weakened by a tumor or cyst).

Anatomic location of fracture

Intra-articular

  • Fracture line extends within a joint.

Extra-articular

  • Fracture does not extend into a joint; may involve the epiphysis, metaphysis, or shaft (diaphysis) of the bone. This topic focuses on extra-articular fractures.

Classification system for specific fractures[3]

Long bone fractures in adults can be categorized in several ways:

  • Gross anatomic location

  • Intra-articular versus extra-articular (head, metaphysis, or shaft)

  • Direction of fracture line: transverse (horizontal), oblique, spiral

  • Linear, stellate, comminuted

  • Closed versus open (soft tissue and skin overlying bone has been opened)

  • Impacted (when one fragment has been driven, or impacted, into another fragment) versus nonimpacted

  • Displaced versus nondisplaced

  • Rotated versus nonrotated

  • Angulated versus nonangulated

  • Complete versus incomplete (rare in adults).

Neer classification system for proximal humerus fractures[4]

Several classification systems exist for proximal humerus fractures, with the Neer system being the most widely used. The fracture is classified by involvement and displacement of the following 4 structural segments:

  1. Greater tuberosity

  2. Lesser tuberosity

  3. Humeral head

  4. Humeral shaft.

Although many fracture lines may be seen, if no displacement is present (defined as <1 cm of separation and <45° of angulation), it is considered a 1-part fracture. If only 1 segment is displaced, a 2-part fracture is present. If 2 segments are displaced, a 3-part fracture is present. If all 4 segments are displaced, a 4-part fracture is present.

Newer classification systems have added articular surface orientation and other fracture characteristics.[5][6]

The AO/ASIF classification system of humeral shaft fractures[7]

The Arbeitsgemeinschaft fuer Osteosynthesefragen/Association for the Study of Internal Fixation (AO/ASIF) system (which was adopted and modified by the Orthopaedic Trauma Association) classifies humeral shaft fractures into three main types, each of which is further classified by specific fracture pattern.

The three main types are:

  • Simple (noncomminuted)

  • Butterfly

  • Comminuted.

Monteggia classification system of radial and ulnar fractures[8]

Type I fractures involve anterior dislocation of the radial head.

Type II fractures have posterior angulation and posterior or posterolateral radial head dislocation.

Type III fractures have an ulnar metaphyseal fracture with anterolateral or lateral radial head dislocation.

Type IV fractures involve the proximal third of the radius and ulna, along with anterior dislocation of the radial head.

Orthopaedic Trauma Association (OTA) classification of radius and ulna fractures based on location and various features[9]

The OTA classification described fractures of the radius and ulna by location, type, group, subgroups, and qualifications. The locations, types, and groups are as follows:[Figure caption and citation for the preceding image starts]: OTA classification of radius and ulna fractures - locations, types, and groupsBMJ Evidence Centre [Citation ends].com.bmj.content.model.Caption@76221b7

Winquist-Hansen classification system for femoral fractures[10]

Type 0 fracture is a simple transverse or oblique fracture with no comminution.

Type I fracture has a small butterfly fragment with minimal to no comminution.

Type II fracture is a butterfly fracture with ≥50% of the circumference of the two main fragments intact.

Type III fracture has comminution of >50% of the circumference of the major fragments.

Type IV fracture has a segmental comminution with complete loss of cortical contact.[11]

The AO Foundation classification system of tibial shaft fractures[12]

The AO Foundation classification system organizes fractures into simple, wedge, or complex fractures. Each fracture is then further classified as below.

Simple fractures:

  • A1: spiral

  • A2: oblique (>30 degrees)

  • A3: transverse (<30 degrees)

Wedge fractures:

  • B1: spiral wedge

  • B2: bending wedge

  • B3: fragmented wedge

Complex fractures:

  • C1: spiral

  • C2: segmental

  • C3: irregular.

Tscherne classification of open and closed fractures in soft-tissue injuries[13]

In Tscherne's classification, soft-tissue injuries are grouped into four categories according to severity. The fracture is labeled as open or closed by an "O" or a "C".

Open fractures:

  • Open fracture grade I (Fr. O 1): skin is lacerated by a bone fragment from the inside. There is no or minimal contusion of the skin, and these simple fractures are the result of indirect trauma (type A1 and A2 fractures according to the AO classification).

  • Open fracture grade II (Fr. O 2): skin laceration with a circumferential skin or soft-tissue contusion and moderate contamination. All open fractures resulting from direct trauma (AO classification type A3, type B and type C) are included in this group.

  • Open fracture grade III (Fr. O 3): extensive soft tissue damage, often with an additional major vessel and/or nerve injury. Every open fracture that is accompanied by ischemia and severe bone comminution belongs in this group. Farming accidents, high-velocity gunshot wounds, and compartment syndrome are included because of their high risk of infection.

  • Open fracture grade IV (Fr. O 4): subtotal and total amputations. The Replantation Committee of the International Society for Reconstructive Surgery defines subtotal amputations as a "separation of all important anatomical structures, especially the major vessels, with total ischemia". The remaining soft-tissue bridge may not exceed 1/4 of the circumference of the limb.

    Cases requiring revascularization can be classified as grade III or IV open.

Closed fractures:

  • Closed fracture grade 0 (Fr. C 0): no or minor soft-tissue injury with a simple fracture from indirect trauma. A typical example is the spiral fracture of the tibia in a skiing injury.

  • Closed fracture grade I (Fr. C 1): superficial abrasion or skin contusion, simple or medium severe fracture types. A typical injury is the pronation-external rotation fracture dislocation of the ankle joint: the soft-tissue damage occurs through fragment pressure at the medial malleolus.

  • Closed fracture grade II (Fr. C 2): deep contaminated abrasions and localized skin or muscle contusions resulting from direct trauma. The imminent compartment syndrome also belongs to this group. The injury results in transverse or complex fracture patterns. A typical example is the segmental fracture of the tibia from a direct blow by a car fender.

  • Closed fracture grade III (Fr. C 3): extensive skin contusion, destruction of muscle, or subcutaneous tissue avulsion (closed degloving). Manifest compartment syndrome and vascular injuries are included. The fracture types are complex.

AO Foundation: AO surgery reference Opens in new window

Use of this content is subject to our disclaimer